How to Choose a Treadmill: 4 Things That Matter (and What to Skip)

June 10, 2018
Treadmill

A treadmill can be the best fitness purchase you ever make or the most expensive clothes rack in the house. The difference usually comes down to buying the right machine for how you’ll actually use it. Below are the four things that matter most when choosing a treadmill, plus the extras worth paying for and the ones you can skip.

Key takeaways

  • Match the motor and belt size to your use: walkers need less than runners.
  • A sturdy frame and a cushioned deck matter more than a fancy screen.
  • Check the user weight limit, the incline range and the footprint (folded and unfolded) before you buy.
  • Always try a treadmill in person if you can, at the speed you plan to use.

1. Motor: match it to walking or running

Look at the continuous-duty horsepower (CHP), not the “peak” horsepower. Continuous power is what the motor can sustain for a whole workout.

How you’ll use it Suggested continuous motor
Walking About 2.0–2.5 CHP
Jogging About 2.5–3.0 CHP
Regular running or heavier users 3.0 CHP or more

A motor that’s working near its limit runs hotter, louder and wears out sooner. If more than one person will use the treadmill, size it for the heaviest and most frequent user.

2. Running surface: length and width

A belt that’s too short makes you shorten your stride or step off the back.

Use Belt length Belt width
Walking At least about 50 in (127 cm) About 18–20 in (46–51 cm)
Running About 55–60 in (140–152 cm) About 20–22 in (51–56 cm)

Taller people and faster runners need the longer end of the range.

3. Frame, deck and cushioning

  • Frame: a heavier steel frame wobbles less. Check the stated maximum user weight; a higher limit usually means a sturdier build. Leave a comfortable margin above your own weight.
  • Deck cushioning: a cushioned deck absorbs some of the impact and is easier on your joints than pavement.
  • Rollers: larger rollers generally mean a smoother belt and less wear.

4. Incline, speed and space

  • Incline: a range up to 10–15% lets you make walking workouts much harder without running. Some machines also decline, mimicking downhills.
  • Top speed: about 10 mph (16 km/h) covers almost everyone; sprinters may want 12 mph.
  • Footprint: measure the space, including about 2 ft (60 cm) behind the treadmill for safety. If it folds, check the folded size and whether it has a hydraulic assist to lower the deck gently.

Extras: worth it or skip it?

Feature Worth it?
Safety key / clip Essential. It stops the belt if you fall.
Heart rate chest-strap compatibility Useful; hand-grip sensors are less accurate
Preset programs Nice to have
Large touchscreen and subscriptions Optional; check ongoing costs
Built-in fan and speakers Rarely matter; a phone and a floor fan do the same
Good warranty (motor and frame) Very important; long motor and frame warranties signal quality

Before you buy: a quick checklist

  1. Decide whether it’s mainly for walking, jogging or running.
  2. Check the continuous motor rating and belt size for that use.
  3. Confirm the user weight limit is comfortably above your weight.
  4. Measure your space and ceiling height. You’ll be a few inches higher on the deck, and higher still on an incline.
  5. Test it in person: walk and run at your usual speed, try the incline and the controls.
  6. Read the warranty and find out who services it locally.

Get more out of your treadmill

Use the incline. A brisk walk at 8–12% incline can raise your heart rate as much as a slow jog with less impact. Try intervals, two minutes of brisk walking and one minute of jogging, to build fitness quickly.

Free tool

Treadmill Calorie Calculator — see how speed and incline change the calories you burn per session.

Open the Treadmill Calorie Calculator →

Free tool

Running Pace Calculator — convert treadmill speed into pace per mile or kilometre.

Open the Running Pace Calculator →

Frequently asked questions

How much should I spend on a treadmill?

Spend enough to get a motor, belt and frame that match your use. For regular running that usually means a mid-range machine or above; for walking, a simpler model is fine.

Is a folding treadmill as good as a non-folding one?

Folding treadmills save space and many are solid, but at the same price non-folding models are often sturdier. If you run hard and often, stability matters more than folding.

Is treadmill running easier than running outside?

Slightly, because there’s no wind resistance and the belt helps with leg turnover. Setting the incline to 1% is a common way to make it feel more like outdoor running.

How do I keep my treadmill in good shape?

Wipe it down after use, keep it level, vacuum underneath, check belt tension and alignment, and lubricate the deck as the manufacturer recommends.

Measurements and motor ratings are general guides. Always check the manufacturer’s recommendations for the specific model.